Eye Candy, Sugar Daddies & Cougars (Oh My!)

The Puppet Will Rise, by Weljin

The dialog that Lanae and I started about men our age dating women half our age stirred up a bit muckety muck. We like that. It means we stumbled into something that needs discussing. Our friend Hugo, who has written and lectured extensively on the subject, added his very male and very academic perspective. Clearly, this is a conversation that needs to be had.

And it was, in comments and Facebook threads and emails. This is a sloppy sampling, that we hope will spark a larger conversation that we can all work with.

Why are so many men our age being drawn to women half our age?

I have no idea, really. Though I can make some guesses.

I suspect that they are looking for sex and good times, in a way that they think will have no strings attached. There are a lot of flaws in this line of reasoning – a lot.

  1. Sex, like most things, gets better with practice. I know that I give a better blowjob at 41 than I did at 31, or 21.
  2. The strings are attached, very attached. I’m sorry, but if a 25 year-old woman is interested in a 45 year-old guy, it’s very likely because she wants something. To be taken care of, to get married, to have a family. Even if she says she doesn’t. At that age, they’re still planning their future, and if they’re fucking you, it’s because they, maybe unconsciously, think you can help them get it. (Especially if you have lots of money.) (Extra especially if you have lots of money, a pot-belly and a hairy back.)
  3. In their 20’s, most people don’t really know themselves enough to be centered. Their expectations will seep out in all sorts of ways: jealousy, manipulation, fighting, games. Those are all strings, whether they’re pulled intentionally or not.

From many conversations with both men and women in their early 40’s, I think that many men have an  unconscious desire  to return to the glory days of their initial sexual awakening. Not just sex, but THAT sex, YOUNG sex. When guys are first claiming their sexuality, in their late teens and early 20’s, there is no responsibility, the pussy is all young, it’s all a party and nothing is permanent. Sex is just sex. Moreover, they are lauded for their conquests. Nothing but fun. They are too young to realize that their partner may be having a different experience, so it seems perfect.

Then life goes on, many get married, get jobs, start families. During that time, for whatever reason, sex often dissipates, and what sex there is becomes a form of emotional commerce. Their sex drives haven’t necessarily dissipated, but their sex lives have. And they’ve become fraught with responsibility, guilt, angst, manipulation, judgement etc…..

When they find themselves divorced in their early 40’s, they naturally want to go back to how sex was, so they look to the last place they had it – the early 20’s. I doubt, really, if most men give it any more thought than that. I certainly don’t think that most men are predatory in any way. But if they’re looking for hot sex with no strings attached, then women in the most dramatic age of their life who are looking for security are NOT the place to find it.

Women on the other hand, tend to have a very different experience when we first come into our sexuality in our late teens and early 20’s. It is a time of tremendous insecurity, of being used just for our bodies, of being called uptight if we don’t have sex and sluts if we do. Much of the time, when we do have sex, it’s to get something, or because we think we have to –  if we don’t fuck him, he’ll find someone else who will, and we’ll lose him. (And we’re still young enough to believe that we NEED him.)  We worry about our bodies, our reputation, our skills. It is NOT a great time for most women.

So when we find ourselves divorced in our early 40’s, many of us have a second sexual awakening. We aren’t looking back to that first time, we are claiming it for ourselves, FOR THE FIRST TIME. Our hormones are raging, biologically speaking, we are at our peak. Emotionally speaking, we have figured ourselves out and have autonomous agency over our bodies and desires that nobody in their early 20’s can have.

What we want are men our age who have the same power and wisdom and experience, who will want us for who we are as people. We’ve given away the sexy bits for too long, on other people’s terms. Now we want to really use it, but on our terms. With people who appreciate it. Ideally, people who want a hot body, a sharp mind, an independent woman – no puppet strings going in either direction.

We don’t want to be your mother. We don’t want you to be our father. We want equals. And hot sex.

Why does it seem so wrong?

Why does it seem so wrong when guys our age date women half their age?

  1. There is an inherent power differential here that makes “true” consent almost impossible. She will say yes to things that she may not want, or may harm her in the long run, in order to get her goal. She is not able to protect herself emotionally because she is putting her emotional self on the back burner – because she hasn’t learned NOT TO.
  2. It is also a weak choice for the man. It’s like an NBA player going one-on-one with a high-school player. How cool does the NBA player really look when he scores? And how good does he really feel?

But beyond that, these men are INADVERTENTLY validating the notion that most young women still have – that the only thing of value is their sexiness. We are drenched in media images that tell us we have to be sexy. Not smart, not strong, not driven, not creative, not even kind. Just sexy. We are only as valuable as we are sexy. The way we get things is with sex. When we are no longer sexy, we will be tossed aside for someone who is sexy. Which is what it looks like when the older guy is with the younger new model of a girl.

When the supposedly older, wiser and more powerful amongst us behave this way, it validates those messages, becomes the acceptable mode of behavior. Imagine it’s your daughter, is that what you want her to learn? Do you want to teach her that that’s her value, and that’s how she should expect to be and accept being treated?

No? Then don’t set that example.

Again, I don’t know ANY men who would do this intentionally. But they do it unintentionally all the time. And it damages everyone. (Including themselves. They too deserve to be loved for who they are, not just what they can provide.)

So what, if everyone is dong it knowingly? She’s getting spoiled, he’s getting laid, it’s equal commerce, right?

Wrong. In early adulthood, women are defining who they will be for the next decades. Just like in early childhood, when we teach children what works and what doesn’t by having clear rules and boundaries with our children. Early adulthood is a polishing of that framework. If we allow women to believe that they can and should use sex to get what they want, they will learn that sex is the commodity of value for emotional commerce, and it will become a game of debit and deposit.

Sex will become a tool, rather than a union. Sex, then, is not about what it feels like or even what it means in a relationship or to the individuals. It is simply a tool. Further, sexiness is judged only by physical appearance and ability to meet external expectations.

This separates women from their own sexuality. Rather than it being a part of them, it is a tool they use. And that can be used against them. It literally removes agency.

This is the first step in making a woman’s sexuality the property of other people. This is what makes it possible for “sex crimes” to go unreported, victims to be blamed, and continue using sexualized images of women as a way to sell products – cementing our belief that it is a tool of commerce, not part of a woman’s body and soul.

So yes, it’s wrong.

As Hugo said to me in a Facebook comment thread:

And the onus is on the older men, too, to see through that. As a prof who works around sexuality/body image issues, lots of female students who first come to meet me are flirtatious because that’s how they’ve been taught they need to be to be taken seriously. They don’t want to fuck me. They don’t usually even want me to want to. What they want is attention, and they don’t trust me (or any other man) to give it for any other reason. After I gently make it clear that I’m absolutely not sexualizing anything, they change. First time in my office hours, it’s miniskirts. A month later, its sweatpants. I take that as a compliment I’m doing my damn job.

But we also  need to redefine sexy. It’s not JUST a hot body, but it’s also creativity, adventure, kindness, smarts…… It’s the whole package. It is EVERYTHING that we are, not just our collagen and follicles.

Why doesn’t it seem wrong when women our age date men half our age?

For me, personally, it seems weird, but not quite as wrong. I’ve had some very smart, hot and awesome guys in their 20’s pursue me in damned near irresistible ways. But I can’t do it, because to me it seems selfish.

I know that I want a relationship, with someone who is well-past wanting to start a family. Someone who knows who he is and what he wants. I don’t want to delay them from finding what they really want and need.

The sex may be fun – and I can easily convince myself that I’m doing a service to all their future women by teaching them what I know – but ultimately, it just doesn’t feel balanced to me.

I want to be emotionally and intellectually challenged – and someone younger than me is not likely to offer that. I want someone who can understand where I am in my life – easier if they’re in a similar place. I want to feel truly free and playful and able to explore the world – and someone younger than me who is just sorting out his future isn’t likely to be there. I don’t want to deal with the head games of youth – I didn’t like them the first time, I don’t want them now. And for goddsake, I want a man who has learned how to eat pussy, and as far as I can tell, that takes a good 20 years for them to master.

However, as I said earlier, I believe there is a direct analogy to a guy’s initial sexual awakening in his 20’s, and a woman’s autonomous sexual awakening in her 40’s. In that way, I think that men in their 20’s and women in their 40’s are in the same place in terms of their sexuality. I think that’s why it is less bothersome when the age difference has the woman on top.

There are OBVIOUSLY  many shades of grey.  Not all men are the same, not all women are the same. And I truly don’t believe there is any predatory or abusive intent. But I do think we are socialized to do things without questioning their impact on us or anyone else.

Speaking for myself and Lanae – and observing many of our friends – the early 40’s are a golden age for women. We are hotter, hornier, smarter and more fun than we ever were in our 20’s and 30’s. It’s because we’ve been through the ringer and come out whole. We’ve been able to define ourselves FOR ourselves, rather than as we think other people want us to in order to get what we thought we wanted.

I cannot count the number of times I used sex to get what I thought I wanted when I was younger. I did it on “their” terms, not mine. To be the person they wanted, not that I was, because I had no idea who I was. I felt  insecure, uncertain, disingenuous, and unstable, but I sure got some skills. Now that I know better, I have all these skills and am a more amazing woman than I ever knew possible.

And for those who value me for ALL the things that I am, and are lucky enough to know the lover I have become, it was worth the wait. No games. No drama. No goal. Just the powerfully awesome autonomous sexuality of a powerful woman, shared freely with a man who values it, to create something greater than the sum of its parts.

No strings attached, because it turns out, I’m not a puppet. I don’t want someone to pull my strings. And just as importantly, I don’t want to pull strings to manipulate anyone else either.

Unless, you know, we’re both into that.


UPDATE: I want to make a couple things very clear:

1. I love men. I love sex with men. I don’t think anyone does this on purpose, which is why it’s a problem.  For every 1 guy who is a predatory asshole conquering younger chicks, there are thousands who are just happy they found one who they think “freely” wants them. Those thousands would never knowingly or intentionally be part of the problem, because they don’t think it is a problem.

2. I have, more than once, had sex with people who I probably shouldn’t have just because I got carried away and it seemed fun at the time. It’ll probably happen again. None of us are perfect. None of us are going to be perfect. It’s okay. The learning curve is long, hard and slow, (oh, come on, I had to.)  But being open and talking about it is the best way to learn.

This entry was posted in Alyssa Royse and tagged , , , , by Alyssa Royse. Bookmark the permalink.

About Alyssa Royse

Alyssa is freelance writer, speaker and coach living in Seattle with her husband and their 3 daughters. She is the former host of Sexxx Talk Radio on The Progressive Radio Network, co-founder of NotSoSecret.com, a site dedicated to empowered women's sexuality, and an Associate Editor at The Good Men Project. She can also be found on her eponymous blog, where she pontificates about food, family, politics and the Seattle rain. Yes, she almost certainly wants to speak at your event, run a workshop or write something for you. Just ask.

13 thoughts on “Eye Candy, Sugar Daddies & Cougars (Oh My!)

  1. Alyssa, I think you’re really onto something here…

    If a man has been married for any length of time (or any other situation that took him out of the ‘dating pool’), yes, I think that some time ago he probably stopped imprinting on himself the idea that his female peers were sexually desirable. Then, if that monogamous relationship collapses, whimpers-out or goes up in 5-alarm fireball, and he is re-awakened to the attractiveness of women around him, I think he most likely will pick up where he left off, as if that dating-sexuality simply had an oversize pause button.

    God knows that, in my teens and 20’s, I spent vastly more time and energy on seeing the women around me as sexy than I did during marriage. The sheer number of “oh my God, look at her! She’s amazingly sexy” moments dropped, precipitously, when I got married. That makes sense to me… something of a relationship defense-mechanism.

    Now I’m in my 40’s, and a few years ago my reality changed to where I began to see women around me as sexy once again. (Not that I hadn’t recognized sexiness in the intervening years, but viewed it with some sort of clinical detachment. The sexiness of other women was something one could observe, but never-again to experience in any intimate / personal way.)

    When my precluding relationship began unraveling, I did ‘un-pause’ my sexual desires and saw the 20-somethings as extremely hot… which, indeed, they are. But it didn’t take long for me to realize that the women I engaged with, who I also found intellectually stimulating and with whom I actually had life experiences in common with, were all at least 10 years older than those of my initial awakening. I had fallen back to an earlier imprint, and realized that this imprint needed a profound overhaul!

    I don’t think we easily forget what we found sexy. Yes, I can see a curvacious and flirtatious high school senior and be stirred by the once-18-year-old within me. What we can do… no, what we ought to do… is to allow our ideas of who and what is sexy to grow with us. If that development has been paused by some form of dating-suspended-animation, we owe it to ourselves and those who we would want to have relationships with, to get ourselves caught up.

    Now, I marvel at the beauty of all sorts of women. Yes, this still includes the 18-year-olds, and the 40-somethings (and everything in between). But I don’t kid myself that I can really have anything valuable or meaningful with a woman in her 20’s or younger, and I’m not interested in an asymmetrical relationship (sex as currency). Just like I want women with whom I can have both fabulous sex *and* conversations about raising my daughter, I want women to want me for similar reasons.

  2. I agree with what you said about how women in their 40’s are in the same place sexually as men in their 20’s. I think there is also something to the idea that men in their 40’s are in the same place *emotionally* as women in their 20’s. Men in their 40’s are often trying to recapture those exciting, non-sexual experiences of their youth. They want to see the world through their child-like eyes again. They want to be with someone who can still see the good in everything and isn’t jaded or embittered by a life of hard experience. I think for a lot of men who go for the younger women it’s a completely asexual thing. I think this is especially true for men who have been devastated by bitter divorce battles or who have spent a career battling women (and men) in the workplace. These men will probably never trust an adult woman again and will always go for the innocence and kindness of the younger generations. Of course, like you said, there are also many predatory men out there who just want to deflower a virgin, or something like that.

    • I won’t pretend to speak for men, or even men in their 40’s, so this is just about me…

      I want nothing to do with ‘trophy’ sexual conquests. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with a straight hookup, but only if it’s on equal terms for the partners.

      I want women in my life who bring richness and complexity (without drama for the sake of drama). Teenage-ish oversimplification worked for me when I was in my teens, but it holds no appeal for me today.

      Are there men (and women, too, for that matter) who have been so emotionally damaged by prior relationships that it confounds their ability to have healthy relationships today? You bet! But the world is so full of people with varied experiences that to cast an entire demographic as ‘wanna fuck a teenager – midlife crisis’ men, well, that strikes me as a pretty narrow view.

  3. Pingback: Talk is not Cheap, it’s Hot. | Dating Mommies

  4. Pingback: She’s a Brick House | Dating Mommies

  5. It has been pointed out to me that hot young things are hot. Why yes, on that we can agree. Ironically, after writing this post, I took my daughter to crew, and was greeted with a whole herd of insanely hot 17 year-old boys in spandex shorts running past, with their t-shirts glued to their torsos with sweat. Yup. Hot. No doubt that my tingly bits were triggered.

    But I didn’t act on it, and I wouldn’t.

    So here’s the rub. Those guys are going to age, and a decent handful of them will have grey hair and solid sense of self, and will be perceived as even more attractive than they are now. They will still get magazine covers. They will even get leading roles in Hollywood films as the hot older guy who gets a second chance at love, with a much younger woman who brings a spring to his step and a breath of fresh air.

    Why are men more attractive as they age and women less? That’s not biology, that’s sociology.
    Why do we see it as a sign of virility that an older man can “bag” a younger woman? There’s an entire industry built around getting old cocks to stay hard like they did when they were young. For women, an industry to make us look young, but not necessarily fuckable.


    I’m not bitching, I’m just really curious about the societal construct. It’s not innate. It’s not biology.

    • Why, indeed? The argument that men age more gracefully than women is pretty easily refuted at any parent function at my daughter’s middle school! In my opinion, it’s pretty much equal. There are slouches and muffin-tops on both sides of the gender divide, as well as hot dads and moms.

      Personally, I think Helen Mirren is a knockout, and is living proof that sexiness in ‘older’ women doesn’t come from chasing the myth of youthful appearance.

      Anti-gravity silicone double-D’s have got fuck-all on a woman who feels comfortable in her own skin.

    • I haven’t heard much lately about older men bagging younger women. It seems like the whole world has gone cougar crazy. All the hype these days is how old the woman can be while still getting boyfriends who are in their 20’s.

      I’m in my mid thirties, so I’m not quite to the 40’s range yet. However, many of my coworkers, and friends are in their 40’s, and some are in their 50’s, not to mention my own siblings who are older than 40.

      Of my male friends who are dating significantly younger women (which is actually a very small number), one of them has never slept with the girl and the others seem to be primarily interested in having a fun, innocent time. I don’t see any of them bragging about bagging a younger girl. These men are having mid-life crises, no doubt. But to me it doesn’t seem sexual at all. They seem to want to be children again themselves.

      My own girlfriend is three years older than me, if that counts for anything.

  6. This post, and the ensuing comments, are a thing of beauty: the rationalization hamster at work, spinning furiously in its little cage, attempting to make the best of its current position. Classic post-hoc rationalization. Just classic.

    So let me count the ways in which I adore this thing of beauty, this rationalization hamster: You claim it’s OK for older women to date younger men, but not the other way around? It is to laugh. Your position is thinly veiled self-interest. You want the widest possible group of men to date: the men in your age group, and in the younger one too. And you want to shame men into not wanting to date younger women. What a joke!

    Look, younger women are hot because they’re fertile. Hotness is a proxy for reproductive fitness. A single man in his 30’s or 40’s who has a bit of swagger and some success is likely going to want to have babies at some point. That’s the biological imperative at work. The whole shebang, from a big picture evolutionary point of view, is all about making babies, and women are most capable of making babies from about 18 to 28. That’s a good range for men to be looking to date if he wants to procreate. Fact: reproductive endocrinologists view pregnancies after age 35 as “geriatric.” No joke. It’s due to the declining fertility, increase in complications, and increased chance of birth defects when women get preggo after 35. Just how it is. Women are born with all the eggs she’ll ever have, so a woman’s eggs are exactly as old as she is.

    Men do have some similar troubles with fertility IF they don’t take care of themselves. Men who exercise, eat right, maintain healthy amounts of lean body mass and low body fat (i.e. men who are hot) do just fine in the sperm department. We’re constantly making more, and our boys are raring to swim upstream looking for some sweet lil ova with which to merge joyously to create a new life.

    So, as a mid-30’d gen X man, I date women of many different age groups, generally younger than myself, and I do so because I can, and nature tells me that it’s not only not wrong, but that’s what’s right.

What Do You Think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s